How to Insert a Butt Plug for the First Time Without Pain or Discomfort

Curious about anal play but unsure where to begin? If you're wondering how to insert a butt plug for the first time, you're not alone. This beginner-friendly guide is here to walk you through the process, step by step — helping you enjoy the experience safely, comfortably, and confidently.

1. Start with the Right Plug

Choose a beginner-friendly plug:

• Small size (1-inch diameter or less)

• Tapered tip for easy entry

• Flared base for safety

• Soft material like silicone

At BlessMyBucket, we carry several beginner butt plugs made specifically for first-timers.

2. Use Water-Based Lubricant (Generously)

Lubrication is not optional — it's essential. Use a high-quality water-based lube to reduce friction and prevent discomfort. Apply generously on both the toy and the anus. Reapply as needed during play.

3. Relax and Take Your Time

Tension is your biggest enemy. Before insertion:

• Take a warm bath or shower

• Massage the area

• Focus on deep, steady breathing

• Try a relaxing environment with dim lights and calming music

4. Try With Fingers First

If you're new to anal play, try using a lubed finger first. This helps your body get used to the sensation. Slowly insert up to one knuckle and pause. Never rush this step.

5. Insert Slowly and Gently

Hold the butt plug at the base and slowly guide the tip in.

• Use a gentle rocking motion rather than pushing forcefully

• When you feel resistance, pause and breathe

• Let your body guide the process

Once the plug passes the tightest point, it usually slides in smoothly.

6. Listen to Your Body

Discomfort means stop immediately. Slight pressure is normal, but pain is not. Remove the plug, apply more lube, relax, and try again later.

7. Enjoy the Experience

Once inserted, walk around, sit down, or lie back and relax. Butt plugs can heighten pleasure during solo or partnered play. Start slow and gradually explore what feels good for you.

8. Aftercare Matters

After removing the plug:

• Clean it thoroughly with warm water and toy cleaner

• Wash your hands

• Use a soothing wipe if needed

• Store it in a clean, dry place

Final Thought

Exploring anal play should be a pleasurable and pressure-free experience. With the right toy, enough lube, and a relaxed mindset, you’ll discover how to insert a butt plug comfortably — and maybe even enjoy the journey more than you expected.

Browse our full collection of anal sex toys for beginners at BlessMyBucket — because your pleasure is worth it.